The new knowledge is written on sedimentary rocks - A comment on Shanmugam’s paper “The hyperpycnite problem”
Carlos Zavala1,2
1 Departamento de Geología, Universidad Nacional del Sur, San Juan 670, 8000 Bahía Blanca, Argentina; 2 GCS Argentina SRL, Molina Campos 150, 8000 Bahía Blanca, Argentina
Abstract In a recent contribution G. Shanmugam (2018) discusses and neglects the importance of hyperpycnal flows and hyperpycnites for the understanding of some sediment gravity flow deposits. For him, the hyperpycnal flow paradigm is strictly based on experimental and theoretical concepts, without the supporting empirical data from modern depositional systems. In this discussion I will demonstrate that G. Shanmugam overlooks growing evidences that support the importance of hyperpycnal flows in the accumulation of a huge volume of fossil clastic sediments. Sustained hyperpycnal flows also provide a rational explanation for the origin of well sorted fine-grained massive sandstones with floating clasts, a deposit often wrongly related to sandy debris flows.
. The new knowledge is written on sedimentary rocks - A comment on Shanmugam’s paper “The hyperpycnite problem”[J]. , 2019, 8(3): 306-313.
. The new knowledge is written on sedimentary rocks - A comment on Shanmugam’s paper “The hyperpycnite problem”[J]. Journal of Palaeogeography, 2019, 8(3): 306-313.
Antobreh A.A.,S. Krastel.2006. Morphology, seismic characteristics and development of Cap Timiris Canyon, offshore Mauritania: A newly discovered canyon preserved-off a major arid climatic region.Marine and Petroleum Geology 23(1): 37-59.
[2]
Arnott R.W.C.,B.M. Hand.1989. Bedforms, primary structures and grain fabric in the presence of suspended sediment rain.Journal of Sedimentary Petrology 59(6): 1062-1069.
[3]
Azpiroz-Zabala M.,M.J.B. Cartigny,P.J. Talling,D.R. Parsons,E.J. Sumner,M.A. Clare,S.M. Simmons,C. Cooper, and E.L. Pope.2017. Newly recognized turbidity current structure can explain prolonged flushing of submarine canyons. Science Advances, v. 3, p. e1700200.
[4]
Banerjee I.1977. Experimental study on the effect of deceleration on the vertical sequence of sedimentary structures in silty sediments.Journal of Sedimentary Petrology 47(2): 771-783.
[5]
Bates C.1953. Rational theory of delta formation.AAPG Bulletin 37: 2119-2162.
[6]
Bourget J.,S. Zaragosi,T. Mulder,J.L. Schneider,T. Garlan,A. Van Toer,V. Mas, and N. Ellouz-Zimmermann.2010. Hyperpycnal-fed turbidite lobe architecture and recent sedimentary processes: A case study from the Al Batha turbidite system, Oman margin.Sedimentary Geology 229(3): 144-159.
[7]
Branney M.J.,B.P. Kokelaar.2002. Pyroclastic density currents and the sedimentation of ignimbrites. Geological Society, London, Memoirs 27, 152 pp.
[8]
Brunner C.A.,W.R. Normark,G.G. Zuffa, and F. Serra.1999. Deep-sea sedimentary record of the Late Wisconsin cataclysmic floods from the Columbia River.Geology 27(5): 463-66.
[9]
Bornhold, B.D.,D.B. Prior. 1990. Morphology and Sedimentary Processes on the Subaqueous Noeick River Delta, British Columbia. In: Colella, A., and D.B. Prior, (Eds.), Coarse-Grained Deltas. International Association of Sedimentologists, Special Publication 10: 169-181.
[10]
Budillon F.,C. Violante,A. Conforti,E. Esposito,D. Insinga,M. Iorio, and S. Porfido.2005. Event beds in the recent prodelta stratigraphic record of the small flood-prone Bonea Stream (Amalfi Coast, Southern Italy).Marine Geology 222(1): 419-441.
[11]
Covault J.A.,B.W. Romans,A. Fildani,M. McGann, and S.A. Graham.2010. Rapid Climatic Signal Propagation from Source to Sink in a Southern California Sediment-Routing System.The Journal of Geology 118(3): 247-259.
[12]
Cowan E.A.,J. Cai,R.D. Powell,K.C. Seramur, and V.L. Spurgeon.1998. Modern tidal rhythmites deposited in a deep-water estuary.Geo-Marine Letters 18(1): 40-48.
[13]
Chiang C.-S.,H.-S. Yu.2008. Evidence of hyperpycnal flows at the head of the meandering Kaoping Canyon off SW Taiwan.Geo-Marine Letters 28(3):161-169.
[14]
Dadson S.,N. Hovius,S. Pegg,W.B. Dade,M.J. Horng, and H. Chen.2005. Hyperpycnal river flows from an active mountain belt.Journal of Geophysical Research 110: 1-13.
[15]
Droz L.,R. Kergoat,P. Cochonat, and S. Berné.2001. Recent sedimentary events in the western Gulf of Lions (western Mediterranean).Marine Geology 176(1-4): 23-37.
[16]
Forel F.A.1885. Les ravins sous-lacustres des fleuves glaciaires.Comptes Rendus de l’Académie des Sciences Paris 101(16): 725-728.
[17]
Griggs G.B.,L.D. Kulm,A.C. Waters, and G.A. Fowler.1970. Deep-sea gravel from Cascadia channel.TheJournal of Geology 78(5): 611-619.
Katz T.,H. Hinat,G. Eyal,Z. Steiner,Y. Braun,S. Shalev, and B.N. Goodman-Tchernov.2015. Desert flash floods form hyperpycnal flows in the coral-rich Gulf of Aqaba, Red Sea.Earth and Planetary Science Letters 417: 87-98.
[20]
Khripounoff A.,A. Vangriesheim,N. Babonneau,P. Crassous,B. Dennielou, and B. Savoye.2003. Direct observation of intense turbidity current activity in the Zaire submarine valley at 4000 m water depth.Marine Geology 194(3-4): 151-158.
[21]
Khripounoff A.,A. Vangriesheim,P. Crassous, and J. Etoubleau.2009. High frequency of sediment gravity flow events in the Var submarine canyon (Mediterranean Sea).Marine Geology 263(1-4): 1-6.
[22]
Khripounoff A.,P. Crassous,N. Lo Bue,B. Dennielou, and R. Silva Jacinto.2012. Different types of sediment gravity flows detected in the Var submarine canyon (northwestern Mediterranean Sea).Progress in Oceanography 106: 138-153.
[23]
Kneller, B. and M. Branney.1995. Sustained high-density turbidity currents and the deposition of thick massive sands.Sedimentology 42(4): 607-616.
[24]
Liu J.T.,H.-L. Lin, and J.-J. Hung. 2006. A submarine canyon conduit under typhoon conditions off Southern Taiwan. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers 53 (2): 223-240. H.-L. Lin, and J.-J. Hung. 2006. A submarine canyon conduit under typhoon conditions off Southern Taiwan. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers 53 (2): 223-240.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.dsr.2005.09.012.
[25]
Liu J.T.,Y.-H. Wang, R.J. Yang, R.T. Hsu, S.-J. Kao, H.-L. Lin, and F.H. Kuo. 2012. Cyclone induced hyperpycnal turbidity currents in a submarine canyon. Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres 117 (4): C04033. Y.-H. Wang, R.J. Yang, R.T. Hsu, S.-J. Kao, H.-L. Lin, and F.H. Kuo. 2012. Cyclone induced hyperpycnal turbidity currents in a submarine canyon. Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres 117 (4): C04033.
[26]
Liu J.T.,R.T. Hsu,J.-J. Hung,Y.-P. Chang,Y.-H. Wang,R.H. Rendle-Bühring C.-L. Lee,C.-A. Huh, and R.J. Yang.2016. From the highest to the deepest: The Gaoping River-Gaoping Submarine Canyon dispersal system.Earth-Science Reviews 153: 274-300.
[27]
Tombo S. L.,B. Dennielou,S. Berne,M.-A. Bassetti,S. Toucanne, and S. J. Jorry.2015. Sea-level control on turbidite activity in the Rhone canyon and the upper fan during the Last Glacial Maximum and early Deglacial.Sedimentary Geology 323: 148-166.
[28]
Manville V.,J. D. L. White.2003. Incipient granular mass flows at the base of sediment-laden floods, and the roles of flow competence and flow capacity in the deposition of stratified bouldery sands.Sedimentary Geology 155(1-2): 157-173. doi:10.1016/S0037-0738 (02)00294-4.
[29]
Marr J.G.,P.A. Harff,G. Shanmugam, and G. Parker.2001. Experiments on subaqueous sandy gravity flows: The role of clay and water content in flow dynamics and depositional structures.GSA Bulletin 113: 1377-1386.
[30]
Mear Y.1984. Séquences et unités sédimentaires du glacis rhodanien (Méditerranée Occidentale).Unpublished Thesis (3rd cycle), Université de Perpignan. Laboratoire de sédimentologie et géochimie marines 251p.
[31]
Meleddu A., G. Deiana, E.M. Paliaga, S. Todde and P.E. Orrù.2016. Continental shelf and slope geomorphology: marine slumping and hyperpycnal flows (Sardinian southern continental margin, Italy).Geografia Fisica e Dinamica Quaternaria 39(2): 183-192 doi:10.4461/GFDQ2016.39.17
[32]
Milliman J.D.,J. Snow,J.M. Jaeger, and C.A. Nittrouer.1996. Catastrophic discharge of fluvial sediment to the ocean; evidence of jokulhlaups events in the Alsek Sea valley, Southeast Alaska (USA).IAHS-AISH Publication 236: 367-379.
[33]
Mulder, T.,E. Chapron. 2011. Flood deposits in continental and marine environments: Character and significance, In: R. M. Slatt and C. Zavala, (Eds)., Sediment transfer from shelf to deep water—Revisiting the delivery system. AAPG Studies in Geology 61: 1-30.
[34]
Mulder T.,S. Migeon,B. Savoye, and J.C. Faugeres.2001. Inversely graded turbidite sequences in the deep Mediterranean: a record of deposits from flood-generated turbidity currents.Geo-Marine Letters 21(2): 86-93.
[35]
Mulder T.,S. Zaragosi,J.-M. Jouanneau,G. Bellaiche,S. Guerinaud, and J. Querneau.2009. Deposits related to the failure of the Malpasset Dam in 1959. An analogue for hyperpycnal deposits from jökulhlaups.Marine Geology 260(1-4): 81-89.
[36]
Mutti E.1992. Turbidite sandstones. AGIP - Istituto di Geologia Università di Parma, San Donato Milanese 275 p.
[37]
Mutti, E. and F. Ricci Lucchi.1972. Le torbiditi dell'Appennino Settentrionale: introduzione all'analisi di facies.Memorie della Società Geologica Italiana 11: 161-199.
[38]
Mutti E.,N. Mavilla,S. Angella,L.L. Fava.1999. An introduction to the analysis of ancient turbidite basins from an outcrop perspective.AAPG Continuing Education Course Note 39: 1-98.
[39]
Normark, W.R. and J.A. Reid.2003. Extensive deposits on the Pacific plate from Late Pleistocene North American glacial lake outbursts. TheJournal of Geology 111(6): 617-637.
[40]
Parsons J.D.,C.T. Friedrichs, D. Mohrig, P. Traykovski, J. Imran, J.P.M. Syvitski, G. Parker, P. Puig, J. Buttles, and M.H. Garcia. 2007. The mechanics of marine sediment gravity flows, Continental Margin Sedimentation: from sediment transport to sequence stratigraphy. In: Nittrouer, C.A., J.A. Austin, M.E. Field, J.H. Kravitz, J.P.M. Syvitski, and P.L. Wiberg, (Eds.), International Association of Sedimentologists, Special Publication 37: 275-337.
[41]
Paull C.K.,M. McGann,E.J. Sumner,P.M. Barnes,E.M. Lundsten,K. Anderson,R. Gwiazda,B. Edwards, and D.W. Caress.2014. Sub-decadal turbidite frequency during the early Holocene: Eel Fan, offshore northern California.Geology 42(10): 855-858.
[42]
Postma G.,W. Nemec, and K.L. Kleinspehn.1988. Large floating clasts in turbidites: a mechanism for their emplacement.Sedimentary Geology 58(1): 47-61. doi:10.1016/0037-0738(88)90005-X
[43]
Prior, D.B.,B.D. Bornhold. 1990. The underwater development of Holocene fan deltas, in: Colella, A., and D.B. Prior, (Eds.), Coarse-Grained Deltas. International Association of Sedimentologists Special Publication 10: 75-90.
[44]
Reid, J. A. and W. R. Normark.2003. Tufts Submarine Fan: Turbidity Current Gateway to Escanaba Trough. U.S. Geological Survey Bulletin 2216, 23 pp.
[45]
Romans B.W.,W.R. Normark,M.M. McGann,J.A. Covault, and S.A. Graham.2009. Coarse-grained sediment delivery and distribution in the Holocene Santa Monica Basin, California: Implications for evaluating source-to-sink flux at millennial time scales.GSA Bulletin 121(9-10): 1394-1408.
[46]
Sacchi M.,F. Molisso,C. Violante,E. Esposito,D. Insinga,C. Lubritto,S. Porfido and T. Tóth.2009. Insights into flood-dominated fan-deltas: very high-resolution seismic examples off the Amalfi cliffed coasts, eastern Tyrrhenian Sea.Geological Society, London, Special Publications 322: 33-71.
[47]
Sanders J.E.1965. Primary sedimentary structures formed by turbidity currents and related sedimentation mechanisms. In: Middleton, G.V. (Ed.), Primary Sedimentary Structures and their Hydrodinamic Interpretation. Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists, Special Publication 12: 192-219.
[48]
Savoye B.,N. Babonneau,B. Dennielou and M. Bez.2009. Geological overview of the Angola-Congo Margin, the Congo deep-sea fan and its submarine valleys.Deep Sea Research, Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography 56: 2169-2182.
[49]
Shanmugam G.1996. High-density turbidity currents, are they sandy debris flows?Journal of Sedimentary Research 66: 2-10.
[50]
Shanmugam G.1997. The Bouma sequence and the turbidite mind set.Earth-Science Reviews 42: 201-229.
[51]
Shanmugam G.2012. New perspectives on deep-water sandstones, origin, recognition, initiation, and reservoir quality. In Handbook of Petroleum Exploration and Production, vol. 9, 524. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
[52]
Shanmugam G.2015. The landslide problem.Journal of Palaeogeography 4(2): 109-166.
[53]
Shanmugam G.2018. The hyperpycnite problem. Journal of Palaeogeography 7(3):6. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42501-018-0001-7
[54]
Sohn Y.K.1997. On traction-carpet sedimentation.Journal of Sedimentary Research 67(3): 502-509.
[55]
Steel E.,A.R. Simms,J. Warrick, and Y. Yokoyama.2016. Highstand shelf fans: The role of buoyancy reversal in the deposition of a new type of shelf sand body.GSA Bulletin 128(11-12): 1717-1724.
[56]
Sumner E.J.,L.A. Amy and P.J. Talling.2008. Deposit structure and processes of sand deposition from decelerating sediment suspensions.Journal of Sedimentary Research 78(8): 529-547.
[57]
Violante C.2009. Rocky coast: geological constraints for hazard assessment. In: Violante, C. (Ed.) Geohazard in Rocky Coastal Areas. The Geological Society of London, Special Publications 322, 1-31.
[58]
Warrick J.A.,J.D. Milliman.2003. Hyperpycnal sediment discharge from semi-arid southern California rivers—implications for coastal sediment budgets.Geology 31(9): 781-784.
[59]
Wynn R.B.,B.T. Cronin, and J. Peakall.2007. Sinuous deep-water channels: genesis, geometry and architecture.Marine and Petroleum Geology 24(6-9): 341-387.
[60]
Yang R.,Z. Jin,A.J. Van Loon,Z. Han, and A. Fan, 2017a. Climatic and tectonic controls of lacustrine hyperpycnite origination in the Late Triassic Ordos Basin, central China: Implications for unconventional petroleum development.AAPG Bulletin 101: 95-117.
[61]
Yang R.,A. Fan, Z. Han, and A.J. Van Loon. 2017b. Lithofacies and origin of the Late Triassic muddy gravity-flow deposits in the Ordos Basin, central China. Marine and Petroleum Geology 85: 194-219. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2017.05.005.
[62]
Zavala C.2018. Types of hyperpycnal flows and related deposits in lacustrine and marine basins. IAS, 20th International Sedimentological Congress, August 13-17 2018. Quebec City, Canada. Abstract book.
[63]
Zavala C.,M. Arcuri.2016. Intrabasinal and extrabasinal turbidites: Origin and distinctive characteristics.Sedimentary Geology 337: 36-54.
[64]
Zavala C.,S.X. Pan.2018. Hyperpycnal flows and hyperpycnites: origin and distinctive characteristics.Lithologic Reservoirs 30(1): 1-27.
[65]
Zavala C., Blanco Valiente L., andVallez Y., 2008. The origin of lofting rhythmites. Lessons from thin sections. AAPG HEDBERG CONFERENCE “Sediment Transfer from Shelf to Deepwater - Revisiting the Delivery Mechanisms”. March 3-7, 2008 - Ushuaia-Patagonia, Argentina.
[66]
Zavala C.,M. Arcuri, and L. Blanco Valiente.2012. The importance of plant remains as a diagnostic criteria for the recognition of ancient hyperpycnites.Revue de Paléobiologie, Genéve, Vol. spéc. 11: 457-469.
[67]
Zhang Y.,Z. Liu,Y. Zhao,C. Colin,X. Zhang,M. Wang,S. Zhao, and B. Kneller.2018. Long-term in situ observations on typhoon-triggered turbidity currents in the deep sea.Geology 46(8): 675-678. DOI: 10.1130/G45178.1
[68]
Zuffa G.G.,W.R. Normark,F. Serra, and C.A. Brunner.2000. Turbidite megabeds in an oceanic rift valley recording Jokulhlaups of late Pleistocene glacial lakes of the western United States.The Journal of Geology 108(3): 253-274.
2019, Vol. 8 
