In recent years,the Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition and English Edition) continually received some manuscripts. The authors of these manuscripts,according to the viewpoint and method of Miall's paper(1985),selected rocks from each bed in the clastic sections of their study areas and induced some rock types,such as conglomerates,sandstones and fine-grained stones,and considered them as lithofacies. It does not conform to the definition of lithofacies. I wrote some papers,i.e.,Feng(2018,2019,2020),to point out the problems and hope that the authors worldwide,especially Chinese authors,will not continually cite,spread and follow of viewpoint and method of Miall's paper(1985) blindly. Prof. Miall is the first person who considered rocks(in fact,the sediments)as lithofacies and proposed a facies analysis method. His viewpoint and facies analysis method confused the definition of facies and facies analysis method. My current paper is a special article to discuss the principal problems of Miall's paper(1985),i.e.,he considered the sediments as lithofacies and utilized lithofacies to analyze facies,but not to discuss the contributions and less strictness of architectural elements of his paper.Here,I have to declare that the facies in my current paper is the facies of sedimentary petrology,but not of other geological disciplines,such as igneous petrology,metamorphic petrology,palaeontology,stratigraphy,geophysics,geochemistry.Certainly,the definitions of facies and lithofacies are controversial. I will adhere to the policy of “A hundred flowers blossom and a hundred schools of thought contend” and hope that through academic discussions,contends and geological practice,these problems will be solved gradually.
[1] 北京石油学院矿物岩石教研室. 1961. 沉积岩石学. 北京: 中国工业出版社,1-263.
[Mineralogy and Petrology Section of Beijing Petroleum Institute. 1961. Sedimentary Petrology. Beijing: China Industry Press,1-263]
[2] 地球科学大辞典编辑委员会. 2006. 地球科学大辞典·基础学科卷. 北京: 地质出版社,1-1173.
[Editorial Committee of a Dictionary of Earth Sciences. 2006. A Dictionary of Earth Sciences(Basic Disciplines Volume). Beijing: Geological Publishing House,1-1173]
[3] 冯增昭. 1994. 沉积岩石学(第二版),下册. 北京: 石油工业出版社,1-326.
[Feng Z Z. 1994. Sedimentary Petrology(Vol. 2). Beijing: Petroleum Industry Press,1-326]
[4] 冯增昭. 2004. 单因素分析多因素综合作图法: 定量岩相古地理重建. 古地理学报, 6(1): 3-19.
[Feng Z Z. 2004. Single factor analysis and multifactor comprehensive mapping method: reconstruction of quantitative lithofacies palaeogeography. Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition), 6(1): 3-19]
[5] 冯增昭. 2016. 论古地理图. 古地理学报, 18(3): 285-314.
[Feng Z Z. 2016. On palaeogeographic map. Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition), 18(3): 285-314]
[6] 冯增昭. 2018. 主编的话: 岩石不是岩相. 古地理学报, 20(3): 452.
[Feng Z Z. 2018. Words of the Editor-in-Chief: rocks don't be lithofacies. Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition), 20(3): 452]
[7] 冯增昭. 2020. 沉积相的一些术语定义的评论. 古地理学报, 22(2): 207-220.
[Feng Z Z. 2020. A review on the definitions of terms of sedimentary facies. Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition), 22(2): 207-220]
[8] 冯增昭,包洪平,贾进华,王一刚,邓秀芹. 2013. 岩相古地理为油气勘探之指南. 见: 冯增昭. 中国沉积学·第二版(下册).北京: 石油工业出版社,1760-1792.
[Feng Z Z,Bao H P,Jia J H,Wang Y G,Deng X Q. 2013. Lithofacies palaeogeography as a guide to petroleum exploration. In: Feng Z Z(ed). Sedimentology of China,Second Endition(Part two). Beijing: Petroleum Inductry Press,1760-1792]
[9] 华东石油学院岩矿教研室. 1982. 沉积岩石学(下册). 北京: 石油工业出版社,1-256.
[Mineralogy and Petrology Section of East China Petroleum Institute. 1982. Sedimentary Petrology(Volume 2). Beijing: Petroleum Industry Press,1-256]
[10] 鲁欣著. 1953. 张介涛等译. 1955. 沉积岩石学原理(中册). 北京: 地质出版社,1-174.
[Рухин Л Б. 1953. Translated by Zhang Jie-Tiao, et al. 1955. Principles of Sedimentary Petrology(Volume 2). Beijing: Geological Publishing House,1-174]
[11] 毛泽东. 1937. 实践论. 见: 毛泽东选集·第一卷(1966年7月横排本). 北京: 人民出版社,259-273.
[Mao T T. 1937. On Practice. In: Selected Works of Mao Tse-Tung(Volume1). Beijing: People's Publishing House,295-309]
[12] 毛泽东. 1957. 关于人民内部矛盾的问题. 见: 毛泽东选集·第5卷. 北京: 人民出版社,363-402.
[Mao T T. 1957. On the correct handling of contradictions among the people. In: Selected Works of Mao Tes-Tung(Volume 5). Beijing: People's Publishing House,384-421]
[13] American Geological Institute. 1973. Glossary of Geology. American Geological Institute,Washington D C: 1-805.
[14] Feng Z Z. 2016. On palaeogeographic map. Journal of Palaeogeography, 5(1): 1-27.
[15] Feng Z Z. 2019. A review on the definitions of terms of sedimentary facies. Journal of Palaeogeography, 8(4): 321-331.
[16] Feng Z Z,Zheng X J,Bao Z D,Jin Z K,Wu S H,He Y B,Peng Y M,Yang Y Q,Zhang J Q,Zhang Y S. 2014. Quantitative lithofacies palaeogeography. Journal of palaeogeography, 3(1): 1-34.
[17] Miall A D. 1985. Architectural-elements analysis: A new method of facies analysis applied to fluvial deposits. Earth-science Review, 22: 261-308.
[18] Moore R C. 1949. Meaning of facies. In: Longwell C R(ed). Sedimentary Facies in Geologic History. The Geological Society of America,Memoir, 39: 1-471.
