Wireline log response-based recognition and evaluation of diagenetic facies in tight sandstone reservoirs: A case study of the Member 3 of Paleogene Shahejie Formation in Raoyang sag of Jizhong Depression
Zhang Kaixun1, Bai Guoping1, 2, Wang Quan3, Niu Xinjie3, Li Qiuwei1, Lu Xiaoxin4
1 College of Geosciences,China University of Petroleum(Beijing),Beijing 102249; 2 State Key Laboratory of Petroleum Resources and Prospecting,China University of Petroleum(Beijing),Beijing 102249; 3 PetroChina Huabei Company,Renqiu 062552,Hebei; 4 SINOCHEM Petroluem Exploration and Production Co.,Ltd., Beijing 100031;
Abstract Based on the observation of bore cores and thin sections, combined with well logging and drilling data,this study documents the characteristics of diagenesis and diagenetic facies of the tight sandstones in the Member 3 of Paleogene Shahejie Formation in Raoyang sag of Jizhong Depression. The sandstones have undergone compaction,cementation,dissolution and fracturing,and they are at the phase A of the intermediate diagenetic stage. Five types of diagenetic facies are recognized on the basis of the type and intensity of diagenesis and diagenetic minerals. They are tightly compacted,clay mineral pore-filling,carbonate cemented,unstable components dissolved and moderately compacted-weakly cemented diagenetic facies. The sonic,gamma ray logs and resistivity,which are sensitive to diagenetic facies,were selected to establish the logging criteria by calibrating cores with logging curves. With the criteria,subdivision and recognition of diagenetic facies were carried out for individual wells,and then the distribution pattern of diagenetic facies in individual wells was figured out. The identified diagenetic facies match with the results of oil testing and petro-physical analysis. A sophisticated approach of diagenetic facies is an important method for predicting sweat spots of tight sand reservoirs.
Fund:[Co-funded by National Science and Technology Major Project (No. 2011ZX05006-005) and Science Project of Strategic Research Center of Oil and Gas Resources(No. 2015YQKYQ0401)]
Corresponding Authors:
Bai Guoping,born in 1963, is a professor of China University of Petroleum(Beijing). He is mainly engaged in the research on hydrocarbon distribution in the global,foreign hydrocarbon basin analysis and reservoir geology.E-mail: baigp@cup.edu.cn.
About author: Zhang Kaixun,born in 1985,is a Ph.D. candidate of China University of Petroleum(Beijing). He is mainly engaged in the comprehensive research on petroleum geology. E-mail: zhangkaixun@126.com.
Cite this article:
Zhang Kaixun,Bai Guoping,Wang Quan et al. Wireline log response-based recognition and evaluation of diagenetic facies in tight sandstone reservoirs: A case study of the Member 3 of Paleogene Shahejie Formation in Raoyang sag of Jizhong Depression[J]. JOPC, 2016, 18(6): 921-938.
Zhang Kaixun,Bai Guoping,Wang Quan et al. Wireline log response-based recognition and evaluation of diagenetic facies in tight sandstone reservoirs: A case study of the Member 3 of Paleogene Shahejie Formation in Raoyang sag of Jizhong Depression[J]. JOPC, 2016, 18(6): 921-938.
[1] 丁圣,钟思瑛,周方喜,高国强,刘健. 2012. 高邮凹陷成岩相约束下的低渗透储集层物性参数测井解释模型. 石油学报,33(6): 1012-1017. [Ding S,Zhong S Y,Zhou F X,Gao G Q,Liu J. 2012. A logging interpretation model of physical property parameters confined by diagenetic facies of low-permeability reservoirs in Gaoyou sag. Acta Petrolei Sinica,33(6): 1012-1017] [2] 杜红权,朱如凯,何幼斌,周川闽,王君,白斌,刘伟. 2010. 柴西南地区古—新近系砂岩储集层成岩作用及其对储集层物性的影响. 中国地质,37(1): 152-158. [Du H Q,Zhu R K,He Y B,Zhou C M,Wang J,Bai B,Liu W. 2010. The diagenesis of Paleogene-Neogene sandstone reservoirs and its effects on the physical character of reservoirs in southwestern Qaidam Basin. Geology in China,37(1): 152-158] [3] 付晶,吴胜和,付金华,胡龙全,张海峰,刘鑫. 2013. 鄂尔多斯盆地陇东地区延长组储集层定量成岩相研究. 地学前缘,20(2): 86-97. [Fu J,Wu S H,Fu J H,Hu L Q,Zhang H F,Liu X. 2013. Research on quantitative diagenetic facies of the Yanchang Formation in Longdong area,Ordos Basin. Earth Science Frontiers,20(2): 86-97] [4] 高辉,孙卫,宋广寿,任国富. 2008. 鄂尔多斯盆地合水地区长8储集层特低渗透成因分析与评价. 地质科技情报,27(5): 71-76. [Gao H,Sun W,Song G S,Ren G F. Origin analysis of extra low-permeability and evaluation of Chang 8 reservoir in Heshui area of Ordos Basin. Geological Science and Technology Information,27(5): 71-76] [5] 纪友亮,杜金虎,赵贤正,张以明,张瑞峰. 2007. 饶阳凹陷古近系层序发育的控制因素分析. 沉积学报,25(2): 161-168. [Ji Y L,Du J H,Zhao X Z,Zhang Y M,Zhang R F. 2007. Sequence stratigraphy models and controlling factors of Eogene in Raoyang Depression. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica,25(2): 161-168] [6] 金涛,高日胜,高彩霞,罗强,王建. 2010. 从烃源岩测井评价结果看冀中坳陷饶阳凹陷勘探前景. 天然气地球科学,21(3): 406-412. [Jin T,Gao R S,Gao C X,Luo Q,Wang J. 2010. Suggestion of exploration prospect in Raoyang Sag of Jizhong Depression from the logging evaluation results of source rock. Natural Gas Geoscience,21(3): 406-412] [7] 蒋有录,卢浩,刘华,杨德相,范炳达. 2011. 渤海湾盆地饶阳凹陷新近系油气富集特点与主控因素. 石油学报,32(5): 791-796. [Jiang Y L,Lu H,Liu H,Yang D X,Fan B D. 2011. Enrichment characteristics and major controlling factors of hydrocarbons in the Neogene of Raoyang Depression,Bohai Bay Basin. Acta Petrolei Sinica,32(5): 791-796] [8] 赖锦,王贵文,王书南,郑懿琼,吴恒,张永辰. 2013a. 碎屑岩储集层成岩相研究现状及进展. 地球科学进展,28(1): 39-50. [Lai J,Wang G W,Wang S N,Zhen Y Q,Wu H,Zhang Y C. 2013a. Research status and advances in the diagenetic facies of clastic reservoirs. Advances in Earth Science,28(1): 39-50] [9] 赖锦,王贵文,王书南,信毅,吴庆宽,李鉴伦,苍丹. 2013b. 碎屑岩储集层成岩相测井识别方法综述及研究进展. 中南大学学报: 自然科学版,44(12): 4942-4953. [Lai J,Wang G W,Wang S N,Xin Y,Wu Q K,Li J L,Cang D. 2013b. Overview and research progress in logging recognition method of clastic reservoir diagenetic facies. Journal of Central South University(Science and Technology),44(12): 4942-4953] [10] 赖锦,王贵文,陈敏,王书南,柴毓,蔡超,张永辰,李鉴伦. 2013c. 基于岩石物理相划分的储集层孔隙结构分类评价: 以鄂尔多斯盆地姬塬地区长8油层组为例. 石油勘探与开发, 40(5): 566-573. [Lai J,Wang G W,Chen M,Wang S N,Chai Y,Cai C,Zhang Y C,Li J L. 2013c. Pore structures evaluation of low permeability clastic reservoirs based on petrophysical facies: A case study on Chang 8 reservoir in the Jiyuan region,Ordos Basin. Petroleum Exploration and Development,40(5): 566-573]. [11] 赖锦,王贵文,信毅,周磊,肖承文,韩闯,郑新年,吴庆宽. 2014. 库车坳陷巴什基奇克组致密砂岩气储集层成岩相分析. 天然气地球科学,25(7): 1019-1032. [Lai J,Wang G W,Xin Y,Zhou L,Xiao C W,Han C,Zheng X N,Wu Q K. 2014a. Diagenetic facies analysis of tight sandstone gas reservoir of Bashijiqike Formation in Kuqa Depression. Natural Gas Geoscience,25(7): 1019-1032] [12] 兰叶芳,邓秀芹,程党性,黄锦绣. 2014. 鄂尔多斯盆地华庆地区长6油层组砂岩成岩相及储集层质量评价. 岩石矿物学杂志,33(1): 51-63. [Lan Y F,Deng X Q,Cheng D X,Huang J X. 2014. Diagenetic facies and reservoir quality evaluation of Chang 6 sandstone reservoir in the upper Triassic Yanchang Formation of Huaqing area,Ordos Basin. Acta Petrologica Et Mineralogica,33(1): 51-63] [13] 李易隆,贾爱林,何东博. 2013. 致密砂岩有效储集层形成的控制因素. 石油学报,34(1): 71-82. [Li Y L,Jia A L,He D B. 2013. Control factors on the formation of efective reservoirs in tight sands: Examples from Guang��an and Suling gasfields. Acta Petrolei Sinica,34(1): 71-82] [14] 孟元林,吴琳,孙洪斌,吴晨亮,胡安文,张磊,赵紫桐,施立冬,许丞,李晨. 2015. 辽河西部凹陷南段异常低压背景下的成岩动力学研究与成岩相预测. 地学前缘,22(1): 206-214. [Meng Y L,Wu L,Sun H B,Wu C L,Hu A W,Zhang L,Zhao Z T,Shi L D,Xu C,Li C. 2015. Dynamics of diagenesis and prediction of diagenetic facies under abnormally low pressure in the Southern Liaohe West Sag. Earth Science Frontiers,22(1): 206-214] [15] 倪超,纪友亮. 2006. 饶阳凹陷古近系沙河街组层序地层分析及沉积体系研究. 中国地质,33(1): 193-200. [Ni C,Ji Y L. 2006. Sequence stratigraphy and sedimentary system of the Paleogene Shahejie Formation in the Raoyang subbasin. Geology in China,33(1): 193-200] [16] 师调调,孙卫,张创,梁晓伟,何生平,任大忠,李春霞. 2012. 鄂尔多斯盆地华庆地区延长组长6储集层成岩相及微观孔隙结构. 现代地质,26(4): 769-777. [Shi T T,Sun W,Zhang C,Liang X W,He S P,Ren D Z,Li C X. 2012. Diagenetic facies and micro-pore structure of Chang 6 reservoir in Yanchang Formation,Huaqing Area,Ordos Basin. Geoscience,26(4): 769-777] [17] 石玉江,肖亮,毛志强,郭浩鹏. 2011. 低渗透砂岩储集层成岩相测井识别方法及其地质意义: 以鄂尔多斯盆地姬塬地区长8油层组储集层为例. 石油学报,32(5): 820-827. [Shi Y J,Xiao L,Mao Z Q,Guo H P. 2011. An identification method for diagenetic facies with well logs and its geological significance in low-permeability sandstones: A case study on Chang 8 reservoirs in the Jiyuan region,Ordos Basin. Acta Petrolei Sinica,32(5): 820-827] [18] 孙海涛,钟大康,刘洛夫,张思梦. 2010. 沾化凹陷沙河街组砂岩透镜体表面与内部碳酸盐胶结作用的差异及其成因. 石油学报,2010,31(2): 246-252. [Sun H T,Zhong D K,Liu L F,Zhang S M. Carbonate cementation difference and its origin between exterior and interior surfaces of lenticular sandbody in Shahejie Formation of Zhanhua Depression. Acta Petrolei Sinica,31(2): 246-252] [19] 王建,马顺平,罗强,国建英,崔周旗. 2009. 渤海湾盆地饶阳凹陷烃源岩再认识与资源潜力分析. 石油学报,30(1): 51-55. [Wang J,Ma S P,Luo Q,Guo J Y,Cui Z Q. 2009. Recognition and resource potential of source rocks in Raoyang Sag of Bohai Bay Basin. Acta Petrolei Sinica,30(1): 51-55] [20] 王启宇,牟传龙,陈小炜,康建威. 2014. 准噶尔盆地及周缘地区石炭系岩相古地理特征及油气基本地质条件. 古地理学报,16(5): 655-671. [Wang Q Y,Mou C L,Chen X W,Kang J W. 2014. Palaeogeographic characteristics and basic geological conditions of petroleum of the carboniferous in Junggar Basin and its adjacent areas. Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition),16(5): 655-671] [21] 王权,金凤鸣,王素卿,乔晓霞,司继伟,李清. 2008. 饶阳凹陷岩性地层油藏控制因素与成藏模式. 新疆石油地质,29(5): 595-598. [Wang Q,Jin F M,Wang S Q,Qiao X X,Si J W,Li Q. 2008. Control factor and reservoir-forming pattern of lithologic-stratigraphic reservoirs in Raoyang Sag. Xinjiang Petroleum Geology,29(5): 595-598] [22] 魏文文,黄思静,郇金来. 2011. 伊利石形成相关反应的热力学计算及其对砂岩成岩作用研究的意义. 地质科技情报,30(1): 20-25. [Wei W W,Huang S J,Huan J L. 2011. Thermodynamic calculation of illite formation and its significance on research of sandstone diagenesis. Geological Science and Technology Information,30(1): 20-25] [23] 杨帆,于兴河,张峰,李胜利,任小军. 2010. 冀中坳陷饶阳凹陷蠡县斜坡带层序地层发育模式及主控因素. 古地理学报,12(1): 82-89. [Yang F,Yu X H,Zhang F,Li S L,Ren X J. 2010. Sequence stratigraphic model and key controlling factors of Lixian Slope in Raoyang Sag,Central Hebei Depression. Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition),12(1): 82-89] [24] 姚泾利,邓秀芹,赵彦德,韩天佑,楚美娟,庞锦莲. 2013. 鄂尔多斯盆地延长组致密油特征. 石油勘探与开发,40(2): 150-158. [Yao J L,Deng X Q,Zhao Y D,Han T Y,Chu M J,Pang J L. 2013. Characteristics of tight oil in Triassic Yanchang Formation,Ordos Basin. Petroleum Exploration and Development,40(2): 150-158]. [25] 张大智,纪友亮,韩春元,初丽兰. 2008. 冀中坳陷饶阳凹陷留西地区古近系沙河街组沙三上亚段沉积相与隐蔽油藏. 古地理学报,10(6): 571-582. [Zhang D Z,Ji Y L,Han C Y,Chu L L. 2008. Sedimentary facies and subtle petroleum reservoirs of the upper submember of Member3 of Paleogene Shahejie Formation in Liuxiarea of RaoyangSag,Jizhong Depression. Journal of Palaeogeography(Chinese Edition),10(6): 571-582] [26] 张大智,纪友亮,韩春元,初丽兰,倪超. 2009. 饶阳凹陷沙河街组辫状河三角洲沉积特征及储集性. 中国地质,36(2): 344-354. [Zhang D Z,Ji Y L,Han C Y,Chu L L,Ni C. 2009. Sedimentary characteristics and reservoir properties of the Shahejie Formation braided river delta in Raoyang Sag. Geology in China,36(2): 344-354] [27] 张福顺,朱允辉,王芙蓉. 2008. 准噶尔盆地腹部深埋储集层次生孔隙成因机理研究. 沉积学报,26(3): 469-478. [Zhang F S,Zhu Y H,Wang F R. 2008. Forming mechanism of secondary pores in deep buried reservoirs of Junggar Basin. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica,26(3): 469-478] [28] 张凯逊,白国平,金凤鸣,王权. 2016. 层序地层格架内成岩作用: 以饶阳凹陷中南部沙河街组沙三段砂岩为例. 石油学报,37(6): 728-742. [Zhang K X,Bai G P,Jin F M,Wang Q. 2016. Sequence stratigraphy-based diagenetic study with the Sha-3 Member sandstones in the central-south parts of the Raoyang Depression as an Example. Acta Petrolei Sinica,37(6): 728-742] [29] 张响响,邹才能,陶士振,徐春春,宋建荣,李国辉. 2010. 四川盆地广安地区上三叠统须家河组四段低孔渗砂岩成岩相类型划分及半定量评价. 沉积学报,28(1): 50-57. [Zhang X X,Zou C N,Tao S Z,Xu C C,Song J R,Li G H. 2010. Diagenetic facies types and semiquantitative evaluation of low porosity and permeability sandstones of the Fourth Member Xujiahe Formation Guangan Area,Sichuan Basin. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica,28(1): 50-57] [30] 张响响,邹才能,朱如凯,陶士振,杨式升. 2011. 川中地区上三叠统须家河组储集层成岩相. 石油学报,32(2): 257-264. [Zhang X X,Zou C N,Zhu R K,Tao S Z,Yang S S. 2011. Reservoir diagenetic facies of the Upper Triassic Xujiahe Formation in the central Sichuan basin. Acta Petrolei Sinica,32(2): 257-264] [31] 邹才能,陶士振,薛叔浩. 2005. “相控论”的内涵及其勘探意义. 石油勘探与开发,32(6): 7-12. [Zou C N,Tao S Z,Xue S H. 2005. Connotation of “Facies Control Theory”and its significance for exploration.Petroleum Exploration and Development,32(6): 7-12] [32] 邹才能,陶士振,周慧,张响响,何东博,周川闽,王岚,王雪松,李富恒,朱如凯,罗平,袁选俊,徐春春,杨华. 2008. 成岩相的形成、分类与定量评价方法. 石油勘探与开发,35(5): 526-540. [Zou C N,Tao S Z,Zhou H,Zhang X X,He D B,Zhou C M,Wang L,Wang X S,Li F H, Zhu R K,Luo P,Yuan X J,Xu C C,Yang H. 2008. Genesis,classification and evaluation method of diagenetic facies. Petroleum Exploration and Development,35(5): 526-540] [33] Alramadan K. 2005. Distribution of diagenetic alterations in siliciclastic shoreface deposits within a sequence stratigraphic framework: Evidence from the Upper Jurassic,Boulonnais,NW France. Journal of Sedimentary Research,75(5): 943-959. [34] Bjørlykke,K. 2013. Relationships between depositional environments,burial history and rock properties: Some principal aspects of diagenetic process in sedimentary basins. Sedimentary Geology,301(3): 1-14. [35] Bloch S,Lander R H, Bonnell L. 2002. Anomalously high porosity and permeability in deeply buried sandstone reservoirs: Origin and predictability. AAPG Bulletin, 86(2): 301-328. [36] Dill H G,Khishigsuren S,Melcher F,Bulgamaa J,Bolorma K,Botz R,Schwarz-Schampera U. 2005. Facies-related diagenetic alteration in lacustrine-deltaic red beds of the Paleogene Ergeliin Zoo Formation(Erdene Sum area,S. Gobi,Mongolia). Sedimentary Geology,181(1-2): 1-24. [37] Dutton S P,Loucks R D. 2010. Diagenetic controls on evolution of porosity and permeability in lower Tertiary Wilcox sandstones from shallow to ultradeep(200-6700,m)burial,Gulf of Mexico Basin,U.S.A. Marine and Petroleum Geology,27: 69-81. [38] Ehrenberg S N,Jakobsen K G. 2001. Plagioclase dissolution related to biodegradation of oil in Brent Group sandstones(Middle Jurassic)of Gullfaks Field,northern North Sea. Sedimentology,48: 703-721. [39] Ehrenberg S N,Nadeau P H, Steen Ø. 2009. Petroleum reservoir porosity versus depth: Influence of geological age. AAPG Bulletin,93(10): 1281-1296. [40] Hazen R M,Sverjensky D A,Azzolini D,Bish D L,Elmore S C,Hinnov L,Milliken R E. 2013. Clay mineral evolution. American Mineralogist,98(11-12): 2007-2029. [41] Higgs K E,Zwingmann H,Reyes A G,Funnell R H. 2007. Diagenesis,porosity evolution,and petroleum emplacement in tight gas reservoirs,Taranaki Basin,New Zealand. Journal of Sedimentary Research,77(12): 1003-1025. [42] Lai J,Wang G W,Chai Y,Ye R. 2016. Rediction of diagenetic facies using well logs: Evidences from Upper Triassic Yanchang Formation Chang 8 Sandstones in Jiyuan Region,Ordos Basin. China. Oil & Gas Science and Technology,71(3): 34-51. [43] Nguyen N T T,Jones S J,Goulty N R,Middleton A J,Grant N. 2013. The role of fluid pressure and diagenetic cements for porosity preservation in Triassic fluvial reservoirs of the Central Graben,North Sea. AAPG Bulletin,97(8): 1273-1302. [44] Ozkan,A,Cumella S P,Milliken K L,Laubach S. E. 2011. Prediction of lithofacies and reservoir quality using well logs,Late Cretaceous Williams Fork Formation,Mamm Creek field,Piceance Basin,Colorado. AAPG Bulletin,95(10): 1699-1723. [45] Taylor T R,Giles M R,Hathon L A,Diggs T N,Braunsdorf N R,Birbiglia G V,Kittridge M G,Macaulay C I, Espejo I S. 2010. Sandstone diagenesis and reservoir quality prediction: Models,myths,and reality. AAPG Bulletin,94(8): 1093-1132.
